| Platinum | Panada Pizza |
| Gold | 2 Boys Smokehouse Meat & Deli |
| Silver | Kaiser's Sub & Sandwich Shoppe |
| Silver | Tinápe |
| Bronze | Rumi Cafe |
| Bronze | Xena Bread and Butter |
| Top Pick | Darrell's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jessy's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Kelly's Deli |
| Top Pick | The Italian Market |