| Platinum | Panada Pizza |
| Gold | Cheese Curds Gourmet Burgers + Poutinerie |
| Silver | Jessy's Pizza |
| Bronze | White Sails Bakery |
| Top Pick | Andy's Chicken Scoop |
| Top Pick | Bella Vita Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Bentley's Burgers & Fries |
| Top Pick | Big Stop Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Preserving Traditions |
| Top Pick | Randy's Pizza & Donair |