| Platinum | Neptune Theatre |
| Gold | The Bus Stop Theatre |
| Silver | Spatz Theatre |
| Bronze | Bedford Players Community Theatre |
| Top Pick | Alderney Landing |
| Top Pick | Broadway Company Players |
| Top Pick | Casino Theatre |
| Top Pick | Rebecca Cohn Auditorium |
| Top Pick | The Chickenbirger Outdoor Theatre |
| Top Pick | Young Performers Collective |